HTC Sensation vs. Galaxy S II vs. Optimus 2X: Head to head

GSMArena team, 16 June 2011.
Pages: «1234567»

Video camera: HD shooters on the range

The three phones record FullHD video, though they all take slightly different approaches.

The HTC Sensation records 1080p videos @ 30fps in 3GP with 44.1kHz stereo sound. The bitrate is set at 10Mbps. The LG Optimus 2X uses 3GP too, but does 1080p@24fps with mono sound (44.1kHz) with an overall bitrate of 12Mbps. The Samsung Galaxy S II goes for the better MP4 container and does 1080p@30fps at 17Mbps, though the audio is mono (44.1kHz).

By those numbers, the Galaxy S II should have the best video quality and the Sensation should offer the best sound recording quality. And in real-life that’s exactly the result we’re getting.

After looking at the videos in detail, the Galaxy S II definitely has the lead in image quality. The higher bitrate allows it to resolve more fine detail than the other two. Surprisingly, the Sensation actually managed to beat the Optimus 2X in places, despite the lower bitrate (which is spread out thinner across more frames per second).

We've prepared some crops from video frames that should illustrate the differences. Have a look at areas where postprocessing and compression usually spoil the quality: foliage, text, thin lines and fine detail.

HTC Sensation Head To Head
Crops from frames of 1080p videos

The Sensation's camcorder is consistent with the still camera's tendency to produce high-contrasty, oversharpened, warm images. You can check out the videos we recorded for our Video quality comparison (hit Play on the tool's page).

As we already pointed out, you can hear how much cleaner the sound is on the Sensation compared to the Galaxy S II due to the higher sampling rate.

The Galaxy S II always focuses only after the video has started recording, making the first second or two of captured video blurry. The Optimus 2X, on the other hand, adjusts the exposition in the first second of each clip. The Sensation does something similar - watch how exposition "pulses" as cars pass by.

Check out these samples we've uploaded to YouTube - don't forget to click 1080p and watch them in fullscreen for best viewing.

Here's a short untouched video sample from the HTC Sensation 1080p@30fps (8.11) plus a Galaxy S II 1080p@30fps sample (11.4MB) and the Optimus 2X 1080p@24fps (4.1MB).

It's also interesting to see the different Field of View (FoV) of each camera. We've prepared a collage of still frames from the three cameras. The Optimus 2X has the widest FoV, while the Galaxy S II is the narrowest (in 1080p mode, at least).

HTC Sensation Head To Head
A collage that shows the FoV in 1080p mode

The three phones also offer 720p mode. All three record 720p@30fps and the results are much more consistent across the sample. We have YouTube videos for you to check out as well.

We have some crops from 720p video frames as well, which will highlight the differences in how each phone performs in this mode.

HTC Sensation Head To Head
Crops from frames of 720p videos

Curiously, the FoV changes once you switch to 720p mode. The Galaxy S II becomes the widest, while the Sensation is the narrowest. We've included the Sony Ericsson Xperia Arc here, which is about halfway between the Sensation and the Optimus 2X in terms of FoV.

HTC Sensation Head To Head
A collage that shows the FoV in 720p mode

Video quality comparison

Much like the synthetic benchmarks for still shots, the HTC Sensation appears to do very well in the Video quality comparison. Still, if you look at the top left and right corners of the Good light images, you'll see the main source of its problems - noise and compression.

If you watch that test video, you'll see how quickly the Sensation adjusts its exposure after we switch the lights off. The resolution chart video is also very good, though that's entirely static and the video seems to fit the allotted 10Mbps very well - suffering no extra compression as opposed to the real-life action-filled clips.

This suggests that if HTC were to bump up the video bitrate, the results from the video camera on the Sensation will improve quite a bit.

Video Compare Tool Video Compare Tool Video Compare Tool
HTC Sensation, Samsung Galaxy S II and LG Optimus 2X in the Video Compare Tool

As one of the first FullHD-capable phones from HTC, the Sensation was quite interesting to test. There are some issues that could possibly be fixed with a software update, but even without one you can shoot 1080p home videos with excellent audio in stereo and not regret going for the Sensation.

Next Page »

Pages: «1234567»