Reviews - Reader comments

Samsung I9000 Galaxy S vs. Apple iPhone 4: Collision course

Samsung I9000 Galaxy S vs. Apple iPhone 4: Collision course - read the full textIt’s not like you’re out of options. Here’s one. Another one would be to get a friend’s iPhone 4 and another friend’s Galaxy S, put them on a table, close your eyes and… tell your friends to bugger off. Or you can do it the old-fashioned way. Flip a what...

 

Sort by:

galaxy S first :D

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:43
  • LgM6

Impressive!
From first moment i saw the topic knew it Galaxy S will destroy it.in fact all phones to date will have hard time facing Galaxy S.
Great phone,great comparison.

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:43
  • 0yw9

If only the Galaxy S had a QWERTY keyboard, I would ditch my old phone for it. Maybe they will come up with a slider version of it later. Right now, the only version with a slider is only CDMA.

Personally, I prefer a larger screen rather than one with higher pixel density. I'm concerned about reading web pages and other info on the screen. It doesn't matter to me if the letters look sharper. What matters is that I can read it and not have to horizontally scroll. The extra .5" of screen appeals to me more than not being able to recognise pixels.

I find the browser comparison interesting. The Galaxy S has the edge on initial loading while the iPhone 4 has the edge on reloading. The times that this matters is if you click on a link and then click back. I know on my existing N97, the default browser is crappy on how it handles going back to a previous page. Opera Mini seems to cache the previous page to make it faster to go back to the previous page. It sounds like the iPhone 4 default browser does something like this. If it is the browser, then installing a better browser can improve performance on either phone.

The lack of a flash on the Galaxy S is interesting. I believe that the camera is able to operate pretty well without the flash. I would have prefer they compare night time or indoor photos here to see how the Galaxy S performs without the flash compared to the iPhone with a flash.

One criticism about the actual article. Why is it that there is a link to the iPhone 4 specs, but no link to the Galaxy S specs. I think that they should put a link to the Compare page of both phones. That way, it is easier for readers to click and see the spec comparisons of both phones. Putting a link only to the iPhone 4 spec page give a perception of bias on this article.

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:33
  • NGfv

Interesting camera comparison. Much prefer the Samsung, you can add contrast later if you want, but removing it from the iphone is much harder.

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:33
  • nGSL

galaxy wins... i hate apple iphone.. galaxy better in everyway anyday.. better screen, battery life, performance, signal reception and its google... apple should have faded away a long time ago..

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:33
  • PWhq

WOW after reading the review more thoroughly the Galaxy S RAPED the Iphone 4. Seriously, the Iphone 4 only won about two or three of the rounds. That being said, you cant go wrong with either phone.

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:33
  • qp4A

Samsung Galaxy S over Apple iPhone 4:-
1. Android 2.1 Éclair, 2.2 Froyo update just around the corner
2. 4” SuperAMOLED display with a 15:9 widescreen aspect ratio
3. Regular SIM card support
4. DivX/XviD video support
5. FM radio with RDS
6. Notably cheaper
7. HIGH PROBABILITY of NOT NEEDING AN INSULATING BUMPER to make,receive and sustain calls = Total win.
8. Higher possibility of multiple carrier choices AND unlocked units.iPhone 4?You're kidding me right?

Apple iPhone 4 over Samsung Galaxy S
1. iOS 4
2. 960 x 460 pixel Retina display
3. Scratch-resistant, high-quality glass panels
4. LED flash
5. Precise movement tracking via a gyro sensor
6. Possibly better batt life.Android as a mobile OS still need to improve on that.
7. Better OS and firmware support guaranteed.Samsung?Well...Samsung Omnia i8910 HD anyone?

Fixed...there I tried to be fair but bang for buck I'd still get the Galaxy S.

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:28
  • tVvx

Was finding this an interesting review,until i realized that you scored the galaxy s better on the music player and screen , what a joke , the galaxy s is a solid all round phone and one of the best android handsets available , but in no way is the music player better than the iPhone , nothing out there comes close ! fm radio , pensioners listen to that s@*t , and the galaxy s is like a fisher price toy when it comes to build quality, and amoled is nothing special (yet) I have a htc desire and sunlight ledgability is piss poor , if you want a premium handset get an iPhone if you want a Jack of all trades ,master of none, get android , enough said !

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:26
  • 3J7c

I would rather choose Samsung Galaxy S than Iphone 4 because Its not practical here in our place. But Samsung Galaxy S is much better..

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:25
  • t7Eg

Galaxy S is one of the best phones ever made. Same with the Iphone 4 if I had my own choice though id go with the Galaxy S however. That 4" screen is orgasmic.

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:25
  • qp4A

I didn't read it yet, but I like the Street Fighter picture. :D

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:18
  • nC7k

iPhone would be 'one hell of a phone' if those recommended apps in the AppStore would be just a default in 'the iPhone'. Apps, like for example; FileMakerGo.

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:16
  • whAr

i have galaxy S and my girlfrent iphone4 all I can say are both impressive and definitely the hottest on the market,in my opinion for apple fan like my girlfrend, iphone4 is definitely the coolest phone ever, and for the rest of the world galaxy S...like in my case (coming from a nexus one) this samsung it s slim,fast,magnificent screen,double battery life,no need root or apps 2sd it is just perfect for me :)

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:15
  • 0Uec

iphone is much better phone..sorry guys but samsung will never make a good smart phone...never

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:10
  • snRr

iPhone is iPhone. there's something different about it.

3rd :)

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:09
  • 9FMa

galaxy rocks

  • Reply
  • 2010-08-06 22:04
  • 3Iwk

Note: Sponsored advertising links are in green.