Stick with the n95!
Still not enough volume on the iphone. Missed calls still!
Still no stereo bluetooth!
This will also cost a fortune with data and voice plans and 3 year contracts!
Just for the record, I've been using Apple since before the first Mac. I've been doing general Mac consulting, DTP, web-work, and database development for close to 20 years. I probably have converted more people away from Windows to Mac machines than most of you yahoos.
In my small ways, I've tried to help Apple change the world.
Today, I stood in a 3-hour line to help a relative get her iPhone before going on a trip. And, yes, I actually advised her to get it -- it suits her needs.
To put my concerns about the iPhone in a nutshell, they are that the iPhone, even in v1, has the obvious ability to be a great phone+PDA, but has made deliberate choices to avoid that much-needed role.
So I cannot recommend the iPhone to anyone looking to replace their PDA and their phone. If Apple cared, they could have managed that in v1.
Yes -- anyone who uses their phone+PDA for *real* work is going to want to use a collapsible BT keyboard for meeting notes, drafts while commuting, you name it.
I am not saying the V551 is *more* productive than the iPhone, but it is certainly a better phone -- better reception, better battery life, better form factor. It does voice dialing and voice memos. With a new battery it gets about 8 hours talk time.
I've since upgraded to the SE z750a. AT&T appears to have killed the 9-hour battery life somehow, but in every other regard it is a better phone. It is also super easy to transfer media to and from it without going through iTunes/MobileMe. I can operate it with one hand easily, and even without looking at it. Maybe Rachmaninoff could do that on an iPhone, but not your average person. Oh, yeah, and my z750 does just fine at checking e-mail, internet access, and so forth. And I can listen to KPFA and KDFC on the FM radio without downloading podcasts -- nice.
I've done reception tests against the old iPhones against both these phones and kicked the iPhone's butt. The v2 iPhone appears to be a little better but not top marks.
For those folks who claim their v1 phones have stood up to abuse, I can tell you I know a LOT of people with v1 phones who had the opposite experience. Scuffed and cracked screens, etc.
So, if you're buying a PHONE, the iPhone cannot stand up to a lot of phones out there.
And if you want a phone+PDA, the iPhone simply ISN'T a viable PDA yet. The PDA market it ripe for plunder by Apple (has been for YEARS), but Apple is making us wait. Apple should be ashamed of that!
A typical PDA can go online, download apps, etc. -- where are all the security problems iPhone fans keep warning about, and why can't Apple surmount them? (BTW: Forgive me if there are now voice recording capabilities available -- the Apple reps I spoke to both said there aren't -- can I also hook up an external mic, like with my iPod?).
Now, then, if you are looking for an *iPod* + phone, then the v2 iPhone is a pretty good deal -- but that's not what I'd call a productivity phone.
The single best thing I can find about the v2 iPhone is that one can cancel the AT&T data plan and still get internet via WiFi.
I'll agree with everyone who says that the iPhone is half way there.
It's just killing me that they're taking so long to get there.
Like I said -- I *want* to want an iPhone.
But for me, it would have to be either a better basic phone than my clamshell z750, or else give me a way to get work done without my laptop (like a good PDA does).
And it ain't there yet.
No one is sadder than me about that.
I also agree, stick with the n95!
Once you pay for data plans with the i phone and then your voice plan, you will be paying a fortune, plus being locked in for 3 years.
Apple still didn't fix their no volume problem. If you ever had this thing in your pocket the tiny tiny little speakers on the bottom would get muffled, translation, missed calls!
Apple still can't give better speakers!
Still no stereo bluetooth!
3G has been around for a few years now and Apple thinks that they've discovered America. DONT WASTE YOUR MONEY!
Buy a Nokia N95, N81, E90 or any other great phone cheaper and better than the Iphone (Crapphone). Choose Nokia, Blackberry, Sony Ericsson, LG, Samsung.
Apple has been in the market less than 2 years, with 2 phones. Dont waste your time, Nokia releases that many a month!
this phone is reallllly great. NO regrets getting this phone...great upgrade for me, eases the business a lot more for me and it makes everything simple. AppStore is the best mobile-application based thing out there. No one stands in the way of the appstore (i have used s60 for a while, not even close!)
haha worst camera? this has to be the best 2mp camera i have seen in a long time i have a n70 and a 6280 with a 2mp and this blows them out of the water with a 3/5inch sceen its much high quality the phone is the best totally awesome!
I know recently, there are many touch-enabled phones coming out, such as the HTC Diamond, & few Samsungs & LGs, but iPhone will always do it for me. I've changed many phones for the past year but this is a keeper, mainly I think, due to its high quality-rich screen & its great design (so I think) of looking like just a slab of shiny black tile when switched off.
There are many flaws iPhone has, which can be easily fixed by other brands. Like all things, you have to give up some things to obtain others, choose your priorities. iPhone's simplicity & its design along with the quality of the phone itself, outways any of the flaws I found (and I know what it's like to have a perfect phone like N95 8GB)
iphone sucks. its useless.... i have thrown 2 iphones already.... it easily cracks....
Anonymous, 11 Jul 2008One thing I missed on my first review was that the N95 (and some other n-series) has the Inter... moreHere in Canada the price difference $20 only.Apple 3G (8GB) $550 ,Nokia N-95(8GB) $570
check oout these kool iphone appz, this will make ya wanna go get iphone!!
how good is this!! lightsaber on a fone!!! :-)
Yes, we never saw line for N95 or N96 phones..But for iphone ? omg..i was trying buy today, but it was not possible...line and biiiiig line, and out of stock
I yet have to see a line in front of a store for people wanting to buy a Nokia N 96....
People what you talking about? OMG, today on July 11th, all ATT and APPLE stores are big and big line, and OUT OF STOCK..2 miles line each apple store, but still OUT OF STOCK...The best phone and, until today, i never saw line for phone and this is really magic...OMG
i see, i dont ever go abroad just stay in uk. so iphone is good for me really. what do u mean more expensive? how much does n95 cost then? do u think i have a good deal £45 with 1200 mins 500 txts and free internet/wifi. i got the fone free with that package
what do u mean u have it unlocked? i am 23 dude, no kids n that, so phone im after is more good lookin and fun features n that! so do u choose the high end n series to iphone then?
mr big, 11 Jul 2008yeah thats cool dude, so the market at the moment, which fone do you prefer? not ones coming o... moreI prefer the original iPhone (especially since I now have it unlocked) as well as most of the high-end N-Series models.
I am lucky to review phones and thus able to receive them at low costs, but the 3G iPhone so far has not lived up to the promises of Apple. In my opinion, they are beginning to do the same thing they did with the iPod: put a phone out every so many months, adding 1 feature at a time. (first there was the touch wheel, colour, video, etc.) so it's keeping you invested in Apple.
Whereas I (and many users) prefer to have a phone that will last maybe 4-5 years max before I can heartily give it to my young ones knowing I used it to its full potential.