If i can choose I Will go for Xiaomi Note 5 Pro or Redmi 5 Plus. Better in everything aspect compared to P Smart and cheaper. Better battery and screen than Xiaomi A1.
could you please give me an advice..I have 250 e to spend on mob..but cant decide between
Xiaomi Mi A1, Huawei P10 Lite or HUAWEI P-SMART..which is best according your experience? I need good camera and before all good video recording sound..or recommend me something else :) thank you!
AnonD-560117, 03 May 2018thank you, for your"s doctors opinion, i have a redmi 4 x and only bad thing that is only 2 gi... moreBetween this 3 devices I wouldn't go for Nokia 6 2017. From some research I've done for u the Redmi 5 Plus and P Smart look waaay better. The displays are lovely in both phones. Redmi 5 Plus has a little bigger display with softer and brighter color reproduction that give a sense of depth and u get a feeling that is more premium. P Smart has a little smaller display with vibrant colors that have a tint of blueish. Wish I could share some pictures with u to understand better what I'm talking about here. U have the option to change the colors of the screen in both devices so they get more suitable to ur preferences. If u check here the P Smart review in display section u will see that the guys who review the phone observed the same thing and they give a color calibration option that really works in real and balances a bit the blue tint but doesn't take it away 100%. Both phones have no connectivity issues with wi-fi or 4g everything runs perfect for me with no dc's or problems. GPS is accurate on both no problems here. They run all programs with no issues but my P Smart gets a little hot when I use many apps at the same time. The speaker is louder on Redmi 5 Plus with more bass, P Smart has more highs and in high volume is a little disturbing to the ears. Call quality is excellent on both haven't experienced any issue while talking. Redmi is a BIG phone that if u wear a tracksuit and u have the device in ur pocket one side goes down :pp (talking from personal experience this guy is super heavy) P smart is like a feather very light and compact. The battery with heavy usage on P Smart and open wifi all day gets me almost a day I have to recharge at night. On Redmi with same usage it rly lasts 1half day. The camera in the morning is lovely in both phones. With the pros and cons I mentioned. At night I can't get a nice picture with P Smart. Also the colors on Redmi are warmer on P Smart they are cold with gray and blue tint. P Smart comes with Oreo 8 out of the box and heard rumors that will get 8.1. (Oreo btw has some rly cool features). Redmi comes with Nougat and rumors say that will get Oreo on December.Both Huawei and Xiaomi are companies that I fancy. Xiaomi has a great community (since u have a Redmi device alrdy u sure know). And btw there are many videos on youtube that compare the device u have now the 4x with Redmi 5 and 5 plus camera. Check them out it will rly help u understand the improvements in camera. Hope I helped, feel free to ask anything u like my friend. Cheers!
AnonD-560117, 03 May 2018thank you, for your"s doctors opinion, i have a redmi 4 x and only bad thing that is only 2 gi... moreHehe, my pleasure :) Well, I haven't used nokia 6 2017 and haven't heard very nice comments about it, but nokia 6 2018 has a really good camera, video and sound quality. The display is really nice, the build quality is great,ah and also the battery gets u easy through a heavy usage day. Also when u open the device u get Oreo 8.1 update. A friend of mine has that device and he is super happy with it. Well, p9 has Leica lenses so yeah, takes amazing photos,even the selfie camera is absolutely lovely. Also the processor is waaay better than the devices we are talking about now, and the screen even in 1080x1920 with 423ppi is absolutely stunning!!! Love the colors on this phones display. But then the design of the phone is of an older philosophy, with big bezels, smaller screen etc. and overall more money for p9. I use both Redmi 5 plus and P Smart, and as I said on previous post each one has it's pros and cons so it's up to u to decide what things u looking for on a device. Ah, another thing also is the size of each one. Redmi 5 Plus is a BIG phone, especially for me that I'm a girl looks super big and is also heavy, but u rly enjoy looking at this massive screen and playing games. P Smart is smaller, waaaay lighter and more compatible and cute,still big lovely screen!! :p
DatUtter, 03 May 2018Ok I never had any problems taking great picture but then im not taking alot of them. Its usua... moreWell, I like taking pictures I'm using the phone camera daily taking few shots. I don't have high demands and I don't except the quality of my dslr camera. But, comparing the pictures taken with my P Smart in low light with pictures taken with other phones like P9 lite, iphone 6, G Flex 2, Redmi 5 Plus, the quality of the pictures are below average. Colors are not accurate, they are more cold with gray and blue tint, they have tons of noise, and they objects are full of pixels like taken with an old web camera, with 640x480 resolution. Especially the selfie camera is a total mess. And it is supposed to be 5mp while the other devices i mentioned except Redmi 5 plus that has also 5mp, are lower.That's my experience with the camera of this phone when I use it after the evening or indoors. And I want to make clear that I have no intention to give bad critic on this device and I'm not a fan of any company, I just share my experience using my P Smart. :)
AnonD-746613, 03 May 2018I use Redmi 5 plus aswell got the 3gb/32gb. Never got any problems with it. No lags, never get... morethank you, for your"s doctors opinion, i have a redmi 4 x and only bad thing that is only 2 giga ram and 16 rom notning else, 5 plus looking very good and I am thinking about it , but I can take a p smart over the operater . My wife has a huawei p9 and it is very good phone with fascinant camera, and that is reason why I am thinking about huawei phone. I forgot to tell you I can take a nokia 6 2017 for that price like huawei p smart, what do you think about nokia 6 ?
DatUtter, 03 May 2018My device never get hot, not as hot you would notice it anyway. If you use heavy apps that dem... moreFor example I have now opened messenger, chrome, youtube and gallery and the device is at 39,6oC the back of it is hot. Not hot like it burns my hand but hot!
AnonD-746613, 03 May 2018Hey mate, I would be rly interested to share pics each other coz with what you just wrote i'm ... moreOk I never had any problems taking great picture but then im not taking alot of them. Its usually in good Lightning. But for what ive seen no blurry pictures or bad colors. I mean ive compared with my iPhone X and the result is good.
AnonD-746613, 03 May 2018If I use many apps together my phone gets hot. And the screen gets stack for some seconds. Aft... moreMy device never get hot, not as hot you would notice it anyway. If you use heavy apps that demands alot of power and have alot of apps open i guess what you experience could happen. I always close apps after im done with them.
AnonD-560117, 03 May 2018my friend i am tninking about this phone or redmi 5 plus, what do you think about camera and d... moreI use Redmi 5 plus aswell got the 3gb/32gb. Never got any problems with it. No lags, never gets hot, everything runs super smooth. The display is different from the P Smart, it's not as vibrant as the P Smart but for my taste I prefer the Redmi 5 plus display, feels like there is more depth and gives u a more premium feel that u can realize if u hold both the devices. But it's up to you, you will be pleased with both devices in terms of display. Then there is the EMUI or IMUI difference. It's a matter of personal taste again both have their pros and cons. On the camera section, people here state that the P Smart is awesome. My P Smart's camera is awful, but maybe I have a faulty device,I'm rly confused in that section. But I can share some useful info with you. Redmi 5 plus doesn't have beauty modes on video recording, only on photos and they are more "light" they don't erase ur face. P Smart has beauty mode feature both on videos and pictures. My P Smart gives more unnatural colors, though Redmi 5 Plus gives more natural colors. If u go for Redmi 5 Plus get the 4gb/64gb coz IMUI uses a lot of ram so it will be much better for u.
MsZero, 02 May 2018Yep, I agree with you. Build material is good and camera does a great job, especially in dayli... moreIf I use many apps together my phone gets hot. And the screen gets stack for some seconds. Afterwards everything runs as it should but the back of the phone is still hot.
DatUtter, 02 May 2018Build quality bad? Its mostly metal wtf. Camera is Great. Done some really good selfies with b... moreHey mate, I would be rly interested to share pics each other coz with what you just wrote i'm very curious if I got a faulty device. In the morning the pics are fine, and a bit to the warm side that I kinda fancy! But in the evening or indoors with no sun light everything gets super pixeled, super blurry and all colors turn gray and blue (white gets super gray and everything else gets a blue tint over it). Srsly it's like taking a picture with a Nokia303. About the metal body I have no problems with that, but I have issues with the noise buttons and the lock button that makes clicky sounds and is like it doesn't fit correctly(hopefully u understand what I'm trying to say here) and that gives a feeling of a cheap device. As for the part of taking photos I can clearly say that my oldest phones take waaaay better pictures(talking about quality) from this device,even my nokia303 can be compared with the P Smart I got in low light pictures.So that's why I'm disappointed by this specific device.
For the people saying there is cheaper and better phones then this. Maybe, but where i live this phone just dropped in price and goes for around 195 euros. Nothing at that price is better. Atleast not here in norway :)
AnonD-560117, 03 May 2018my friend i am tninking about this phone or redmi 5 plus, what do you think about camera and d... moreThe redmi plus seems like a good phone tho, never used one. They dont sell here. Snapdragon 625 is pretty much the same as p smarts Kirin 659. So I think both phones perform similar. But can also say p smart comes with android 8 and regular security patches. Also heard android 8.1 is around the corner :)
AnonD-560117, 03 May 2018my friend i am tninking about this phone or redmi 5 plus, what do you think about camera and d... moreCamera is great, overall performance is smooth. Display is also good. You can choose between lower res to save battery. This phone also have some good built in futures like Antivirus and cleaning program. For me it has good battery life but im not a heavy user or play games alot. Also one think i really like thats a bit rare is the alarm goes of even if you turn off your phone. This phone is an really good pick for anyone that need a solid smart phone for everyday use :)
DatUtter, 02 May 2018Build quality bad? Its mostly metal wtf. Camera is Great. Done some really good selfies with b... moremy friend i am tninking about this phone or redmi 5 plus, what do you think about camera and display and other things?
MsZero, 02 May 2018Yep, I agree with you. Build material is good and camera does a great job, especially in dayli... moreYes I also really like the camera. For what it cost it does some real good things :)