Voting for a phone should end six months after its release date because after six months the technology used becomes obsolete upto a certain extent,people will give it a much poorer score thus not reflecting the phones true impact upon release for example the nokia 3310 or n95 would probably have a 9 plus rating in its time but nowadays rate as a 1 or 2.
Android Phones: D = 9, F = 10, P = 10
Windows Phones: D = 10, F = 9, P = 10
iOS Phones: D = 2, F = 1, P = 1
Are those votes valid? Those are not all 10's and 1's right? Fanboys will still vote that way and thats a problem. I suggest each moderators can vote too, like Chavis, Peter, Vince, Prasad (all 10's on iPhone...) and others, and we users can view there (unbiased) votes.
P.S. I dont vote that way. Thats just a sample. (;
Two thumbs up, GSM Team! Statistics page finally looks realistic in terms of phone ratings!! Great work :)
I believe the iPhone5 current ranking at 7th is reflecting the true and facts.
Great Work!!! Now i guess, we will have sensible ratings on every device...
1. Acer Iconia Tab A511 8.533 10
2. Celkon C7 8.528 12
3. Philips W736 8.528 12
4. Philips W337 8.528 12
5. LG Optimus Black P970 8.524 14
6. Pantech Vega R3 IM-A850L 8.524 14
7. Motorola RAZR HD XT925 8.524 14
8. LG Nexus 4 E960 8.519 113
9. Motorola SPICE Key 8.515 11
10. Sony Xperia S 8.515 44
11. Celkon C007 8.500 12
12. Philips W6350 8.500 12
13. Motorola EX122 8.500 10
14. Samsung S7220 Ultra b 8.500 10
15. LG Optimus 3D Max P720 8.500 12
loggedd in users can also point extreme votes
but a really good move not completely good enough
i suggest you to make a team to make scores for the phones so that the expert opinions and public opinions should be averaged.
Come on guys! Let's go and bring that over-priced, 2-year late from technology, fragile and ugly iPhone down!!!
AnonD-79437, 23 Nov 2012I agree with you , however , the fair ratings will come's during time and new phones which wil... moreThe numbers of user opinions will remain as a testimony. And quite a few of them will remain in use long after you throw your phone away for the new one with twice as many cores.
I hope users can only vote on phones that they have or restrict the voting to a maximum of three phones per user to make this voting more realistic..
AnonD-49266, 22 Nov 2012iphone 5 is getting worse rate now :DYeah lol I just saw it and rated 1-1-1. I think that many did.
AnonD-58102, 23 Nov 2012As expected, the best phone(iPhone) has the lowest scores. Nokia's garbage has the highest sco... moreI agree with you , however , the fair ratings will come's during time and new phones which will change the scales to be more real , specially who were top like nokia, these days is down !!
And wont be top again because it has took its time more then enough!!!
AnonD-58102, 23 Nov 2012As expected, the best phone(iPhone) has the lowest scores. Nokia's garbage has the highest sco... moreWell that means that Nokia has much more fans than Apple on the world's most popular handset website.