1. A (probably N95, good colors)
2. C (G600, very sharp)
3. B (Viewty, not bad)
4. D (K850i, bad colors, not sharp)
I Thing Nokia or Samsung will win.
I believe C is K850i because of true color rendering and excellent macro mode while B is N95 because nokia's cameras tend to exaggerate colors. A and D are for LG and Samsung, I just dont know which is for A and for D. Best to worst is CBAD.
A = LG (not very sharp)
B = Nokia (brightened colours)
C = Samsung (autofocus is really good, but colour not all that)
D = Sony ericsson (just cuz A is worst.. and I dont know about LG)
For me... i dunno... i guess... k850 or N95. I have a d900.. and am really fed up with its slow shutter speed. Samsung is great tho.. I dont really prefer any brand.. but I didnt use to like Nokia, but now with the N82... I'm having second thoughts.
its like this for me:
p.s. if u wanna choose between them u should decide depending on vedio quality.
to the administrator - since the cam fones have reached to a good level, from now on pls try to upload similar pics from a good digicam like sony or cannon. we can then compare the true colors. like in this test i was not sure which fone captured the true color. and btw the idea behind this test (not mentioning the name of the fones) was simply awsomee!!!!! good job!!!
i have seen the pics first then the comments...in my opinion C is the best....then A, D, B
C or A is either N95 or G600 B is K850i and D is LG U990 my vote goes for C, A, B, D
B C A D
LG KU990viewty is the best media phone ever
its touch screen , 3 inch ,solid and simple ,n95 has extra options but lacks the main importent ones i mentioned, the sliding is useless(the media buttons could be on the corner) if it falls while its open it will breakand in hand it feels like a toy.
Dunno guys... but i believe D is a bit better than A. There's not much detail on the background on any of the shots taken by A.
D has the worst color reproduction though. It's too pale...
Anyway, here are my ratings:
OUTDOOR: C B D A
MACRO: B D D A
C - great for outdoors... though a bit strong on colors
B - very good outdoor shots but has lesser details compared to C
D - sharpness comparable to B but short on color reproduction
A - average performance - less details on the backround
Although the thread doesn't really require us to guess which phone is which, I'd like to add my opinion :) this would surprise you but i believe i'm 95% sure.
A - Samsung
B - LG
C - Nokia
D - SE
I am a solid SE fan; my last three phones were all SE's. But i'm quite disappointed with K850. It's still has excellent cam interface and features but I was expecting more on the photo reproduction side since K800 did pretty well during it's time. I'm very suprised to see Nokia improve much in the Camera Phone category. I hope SE can regain the throne with their next Cybershot Phone.
You should've kept a high quality handycam(a 10 or 16 mp one) photo along with the other pics as a benchmark for comparison.That would've made judgement easier.