Nokia 808 PureView blind test Comments
- AnonD-11120
- j01
Here's mine. from the best to the worst:
E - A - F - B - D - C
Cheers. ;)
- kodn
- sxt
My guess would be...
samsung galaxy s 3 - a
nokia n8 - b
htc one x - c
iphone 4s - d
nokia pureview 808 - e
olympus - f
My ratings would be:
1 - E
2 - F
3 - B
4 - A
5 - D
6 - C
- C38S
- PUI
Oops I posted which camera I thought was which but not my preferences :)
1: E Is the best with the most natural colours
2: F does a great job but the colors don't seem natural
3) A has great colours and detail but doesn't perform as well
4) C is next
5 D is next, it could do better light range, the lack of detail in sections destroys the photo
6 B Too much sharpening.
Also note I only looked at the 100% crops... oops.
- torcida
- 3vk
AnonD-15154, 15 Jun 2012Hmm... This was a tough one! Tougher than the first blind test with the Great N8... Looks like... morethe colors of almost all are oversaturated, except E (should be 808) - which is the best and most natural (!!) picture!
- Murtle
- HK%
A- Nokia n8
B- Iphone 4s
C- Htc one x
D- Samsung galaxy s3
E- Nokia pureview
F- Olympus EPL2
I'm no expert but again from best to worst in this order (with my reasoning):
1. F -olympus EPL2 (least noise, may be a tad warm but prefer image to E and shows more shadow detail)
2. E -Nokia pureview, (also very little noise)
3. B -Iphone 4s (slightly more detail than image A, and colours more vivid)
4. A -Nokia n8 (very close with image b-the iphone 4s, has a tad more noise)
5. D -Samsung galaxy s3 (over saturated colours, high noise)
6. C -Htc one x (easily worst image quality, which is characteristic of htc images)
- AnonD-15154
- BJL
Hmm... This was a tough one! Tougher than the first blind test with the Great N8... Looks like its gameover for the N8 and game on for the Great 808 PureView!!
So here's my ranking (Best to Worst)
E- PureView
F- Olympus
B- S3
A- N8
D- 4s
C- OneX
And here's why:
E (PV) -> Detail=impressive; Colours=good;
F (OL) -> Detail=impressive; Colours=poor;
B (S3) -> Detail=ok; Colours=impressive; AMAZING, AMAZING Colours!!
A (N8) -> Detail=great; Colours=good; I have this phone!
D (4s) -> Detail=poor; Colours=ok; Too bright for me, though!!
C (HTC) -> Detail=Yuck; Colours=poor; I have this phone too!
Lol; This sounds like "E,F and BAAAD C"
And that's how I think these cameras compete as; Similar EF, BAD and C
- AnonD-59061
- 8TA
Better Image: F ( Olympus), and the E( Nokia 808) is very near in image quality
Worst Image: C ( HTC ) - very noisy
the order: F(olympus DSLR) > E(Nokia 808)>A (Nokia N8)> B( Galaxy SIII)> D ( Iphone 4s) > C( Htc one)
- C38S
- PUI
Tooooo easy.
I haven't read any comments yet so this is fully blind
A) N8
B) One X (sharpneing)
c) Galaxy - general processing
d) iPhone 4S - lack of dynamic light range, blow outs in over exposure
e) 808 pureview
f) Canon (warm colours?).
The pureview is much better than the N8 than I expected!! Also note that the Pureview in 8MP mode applies less colour post-processing than it does in 5MP mode so the results aren't typical to what the user will see. 5MP 808 photos are more vivid.
- busul
- S6D
not sure about the other,but i guess
F = Oly (its saturated)as usual Olympus
E = pureview (low noise and more neutral)
the details roughly the same
the rest..
maybe D is N8
A=iphone
B=Samsung
C= HTC
- AnonD-59059
- LiE
AnonD-48570, 15 Jun 2012Image E is definitely the Pureview 808.
Image F might be Olympus E-PL2.
I guess N8 would b... more"The colors should be more natural" so it should be the iphone??
lol
- AnonD-59059
- LiE
D is definitely iphone 4s, with the disneyland colors.
Galaxy S3 is probably B, which is also a bit oversaturated.
C looks horrible, that's probably HTC One X as their sensor is just bad.
A is probably N8, since it seems to have better dynamic range and detail than the other three.
E and F are similar in detail, but F has more saturated colors. Since the colors are the same between E and A, I'll say E is the 808 Pureview.
In order of preference:
1st - F: Olympus
1st (ex-aequo) - E: 808 Pureview
2nd - A: Nokia N8
3rd - B: Galaxy S3
4th - D: iphone 4s
5th - C: HTC One X
- AnonD-53178
- 3vk
Winner is E
here my updated list:
1) E
2) F
3) A
4) D
5) B
6) C
Cheers :)
- AnonD-59060
- vV5
thanks gsmarena, helping me in deciding should i go for this phone or not. If pureview netheir E or F then.... I would like to know which device is E.... I am buying it...
Tip us
881k
145k 87k
558k
RSS
Log in I forgot my password Sign up